Three years ago they moved from Beijing to the US where, like many new arrivals, they retained some Chinese habits and picked up some American ones. I once had a slight body odor when I was in a hostel during my school life and that happened because one of my friend who has a body odor used my jacket and after that without washing that jacket I used it and from next day even I started having some sort of body odor, I got panic and started doing some research and got to know that applying lime paste and keeping it for sometime removes the body odor and after doing that the body odor is gone and I even stopped using that jacket . You dont stink and youll sweat less. It reflects the change in the types of labour done, too: fewer Westerners are now involved in the kinds of manual or agricultural work that would call for rinsing off dirt. When her book came out in 2017, older Iranians would tell her they did not agree with or understand the need for her exploration of Iranians complicated relationship with whiteness. Use Your Left Hand Sparingly. Isnt that good hygiene? My daughter eats food at her friends houses too. Fun fact, Indian people are SOUTH Asian, but it is simpler to differentiae when you call them Indian, not Asian or south Asian. Hi Sanjay, May be different body hormone composition. France 80. In the Middle East, cumin really comes through your pores in addition to the garlic, being on a crowded bus was brutal. Deodorant technology has come a long way, trust me. Yeah I dont know I still think we all carry some inherit stank I think its just in the west deodorant has like a 80-year head start. A good way to drop a hint someone stinks is to get them a gift basket with a variety of soaps and deodorant. I dont care about their accent, or missing tips, but their smell is disgusting, sweaty curry describes it the best. I just shower almost everyday and I dont smell. Germany 77.2. Why do westerners not wash themselves with water after using - Quora Apparently, this country in the Nordic region emphasizes the use of renewable energy. Deodorant is the smell good part and if it doesnt contain antiperspirant youll stink like BO and fragrance. Sometimes shell come home and her hair smells strong. So my question is, why the kids? Like many others, I stumbled on this post by looking in Google for answers about Indian people with pungent body odor. What should we use in your opinion? She said it is purposely trying to attract attention and that is not allowed. Yes one can get bad breath by eating raw garlic and fermented food, spicy food etc. Im done !! Still dont know the reason but we need to check this problems genetically or with medically approach. But this is all spinning thoughts. Apparently, the toilet seats are there originally but, then, they break. Doctors offices and hospitals are scent free and request people reframe from wearing scents. Its a subtle way to send a message without being offensive or hurting feelings. Country % of people who shower each week % of people who bath each week United Kingdom 83% 32% Germany 92% 20% Brazil 99% 7% China 85% 11%. Wanting more information, I came online to read about it and found your page thank you for explaining the issue while also sharing some comic relief. They all live together eat and drink the same food living in the same climate environment. HOWEVER, lets be honest: the smell is nauseating and NOT related to food. They eat lots of garlic and dont use deodorant or cologne, they can stink pretty bad. Americans are, by far, the worlds foremost consumers of toilet paper (Credit: BBC/Alamy). Residents of many nations have long been ending a toilet visit with water. Theres also a stronger sense now of showering as a way of making yourself presentable to others, rather than washing away the days grime. Premixing it with coconut oil will even be better in the routine since it will be very easy to apply. In past census surveys, more than 80% in this group have called themselves white, The Times analysis found. I confess that I did intentionally Google this re: Punjabis. The seats break because people stand on them. You do know we can still smell the BO even if you put on deodorant. Of course, everyone can be stinky due to poor hygiene/work conditions/being drunk, but no other race/ethnicity has this issue as a cultural thing. A gas station employees BO was getting trapped inside my mask today. You know who may NOT smell bad though? My wife is a doctor (and also Indian) and Ill run this by her but very valuable and I hope more people read this comment. Please consider subscribing today to support more stories like this. Kuos family has come up with a halfway solution for their Chinese American household. Stray800. Theres no official protocol for how often to shower, but folks around the world in countries such as India, the US, Spain, and Mexico all bathe about once a day (either with soap or without) , according to Euromonitor International. Whenever visiting an Indian friend in the US, I can almost always count on them having a plastic water bottle or a mug beside the toilet., It may have been the French who gave the world the word bidet, but water is also preferred in many majority-Muslim countries, among other places (Credit: BBC/Alamy/Getty). In fact, Anglo-American bathroom trends became so widespread that, in the 1920s, they were even dubbed sanitary imperialism. Sclerosing mesenteritis, also called mesenteric panniculitis, occurs when the tissue (mesentery) that holds the small intestines in place becomes inflamed and forms scar tissue. At stake in the decennial count is nearly $800 billion in federal tax dollars and the number of seats each state receives in the U.S. House of Representatives. An evening bath, as is common in Japan, can help you relax before bed (Credit: BBC/Alamy/Getty). Every time I get an Indian passenger is a DISASTER. The smell hits hard, like really. wow thanks for sharing and good luck wit your chemo at a time like this. I think a bad body odor is a sign that some aspect of the persons lifestyle isnt suiting his/her body type, and that he/she needs to address it and change and improve the quality of living. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I was getting pissed as well because I was tipsy. As the weather was quite cold, all the bus windows were closed so it made the smell more pungent. Other than that not sure why kids would come home with a strong smell in the hair but maybe Im also used to it from growing up . "They hate brown people," Shams told his father as he sipped his favorite lager. On Sale Now. It seems to me that every one in four toilets has plumbing issues. Yet the touch of the left hand does not make the right impure. But were white, his father replied. Heres a dumb, racists, inaccurate joke that isnt even a joke: 4 guys walk out of the gym after a work out. Among the 16 regions surveyed, Americans attested to showering more frequently than the Chinese, Brits, and Japanese, where respondents said they take about five showers per week, but not nearly . From there it spread like wildfire throughout America, quickly becoming the social norm. In point, different styles of toilets and bathrooms can lead to confusion. For the rest of the world, the average number of showers per week is five. Just like we have to find a way to let American people know that TOILET paper IS DISGUSTING, we need to encourage our South Asian brothers and sisters that deodorant is actually spot-on awesome. As m a Mongolian we dont have such gene n secretion from body but Indian people stays in hot country that let them secret more hormones or grow more hair. We keep a little footstool in front of the toilet, so when youre doing your business, putting your feet up on that stool sort of emulates the squatting position, he says, laughing. not just aluminum or organic deodorant but anything which permits good smell in any culture, to each their own. One reason early-20th-century Americans ramped up their weekly baths to daily showers is that marketing companies capitalized on the insecurities of a new class of office drones working in close quarters. My sister always complained how we stank after going out to eat Korean food. Im Italian, I had a friend who went crazy about Tumeric, he started using it everywhere, after a while his skin began to smell quite bad. Sometimes I smell them on my way to work, do they not shower in three AM either? What you eat comes out through your pores. Then I got home, showered but didnt wash my hair because I just washed it right before meeting him, then I went to bed. Our parents came as immigrants and worked with this idea of aspirational whiteness, that if you work hard and put your head down youll be successful, said Khaled Beydoun, who teaches law at the University of Arkansas. But you and I use Google and Chinese goods every day, so please cut the crap that you dont buy into that western stuff. So if someone in your gym or work or school or family is stinking it up, do your civic duty and clean it up. The 36-year-old remembers a conversation he had with an administrator about the lack of inclusion of Middle Easterners in diversity scholarships when he was a student at Murray State University in Kentucky. Im Japanese and I just started seeing an Indian guy I met from a dating app. There are countless horror stories I have heard (even a chef in the UK from India getting a huge fine) that could have easily been prevented by using toilet paper. Thank you for this post I live in Amsterdam and I usually drive to work. There are also some indians who have minmal/nil BO; possibly either from deodorants, which i dont smell any, or food intake, or are furtunate enough not to sweat from home to work Bathrooms: always room for cultural misinterpretation. We love it. She also was pretty not well taken care of and would never lets say hug she was not nice, and the only person no one was speaking too. The same study showed Brazilians, on average, shower for 10.3 minutes a time. More likely than not your Arab hosts will have a special living room or seating area specifically for guests, with the best sofas or decorations. Bathing also varies culturally. I want to see you succeed there too, and its something so simple you just need to fix. Are you a fan of that Peter Sellers movie? Bathroom stratagems are some of the most ingrained and thickly constructed of socialized practices. Harvard MBA, decent looks, great career and family on paperwhat the heck is going on? You lie. I know some white dudes (the hippy kind) who are vegetarians or even vegans and they also smell pretty bad. For their first month, they smell horribly bad. Many Westerners take morning showers, toilet tissue and sitting toilets for granted. Why do so many Indian people not use deodorant? - Reddit Islamic toilet etiquette is a set of personal hygiene rules in Islam that concerns going to the toilet.This code of Islamic hygienical jurisprudence is called Qa al-a (Arabic: ).. The numbers in this story were calculated using the broader SWANA definition. He supported adding the classification, he said, but also worried that the information could be used to track where Arabs or Iranians live or be used against the community during times of crisis., Prior to the 2010 census, the Arab and Iranian communities in Southern California teamed up to spread a message: Check it right, you aint white!. It used to be a luxury item, but now its affordable for pretty much anyone and will take some time to adopt. refugefirstmate 7 yr. ago. Muslims follow the traditions of their Prophet Muhammad, who performed istinja, the act of washing the private parts with water after committing najis, which is the . But they wore deodorant. I work in an IT company whereas most Indians work. Without it, they would opt for white or some other race.. Which country has the best personal hygiene? The bureaus move was seen as a blow to a group already grappling with feelings of invisibility. Even Kashmiris dont smell bad either. Even soap operas got their name from the heavy advertising, on radio and then television, by American soap manufacturers. In some Indian who has less hair growth from body doesnt stink like us. Depending on the circumstances, this can even last a few days. Youll get haemorrhoids., Sitting instead of squatting can make for longer toilet time which Americans have turned into a form of leisure (Credit: BBC/Alamy/Getty). In India people use bidets, clean the hose pipe with warm soap water and then use soap water to clean the area. Its no longer a luxury item, but adoption for the masses will still take some time. Students said they lobbied for the change on UC admissions applications because they felt the Middle Eastern community has formed into an invisible minority. They settled on the term SWANA because they believed the term Middle Eastern was problematic due to its colonial and Orientalist origins, according to the resolution. Deodorant is actually not the real solution. Bad personal hygiene!!! Hygiene isnt just about smelling good. Sorry but that toilet paper thing is just a cope to ease the blow for Indians who are offended. I believe the BO ,besides being emitted ,also stays stuck in certain cloths. They dont smell bad. And even doctors would agree that unless you sweat a lot, even having a shower on alternate day is healthier. Personal hygiene and grooming are a $2 or an INR 150 investment. When they take them out for a walk, they make their business in light poles and trees. Some feel the census should follow the UC systems example. My daughter has experienced their body odour from men at work & later, from a woman sent here to clean while I was in hospital. Its backed up by science. He waved around a portable spray hose, also known as a shattaf or bum gun, as a prop. I'm Muslim and I wear deodorant and I always make sure my body and breath smell good. You can send them an anonymous email like I did. This is why the moment your polyester shirt is on in the gym, it starts to smell really quickly. You should have a shower everyday. A handpicked selection of stories from BBC Future, Culture, Worklife, and Travel, delivered to your inbox every Friday. Never shake hands with them. While advertised to eliminate odor, deodorant was used to cover up the smell of bacteria. Whenever I visited a Vietnamese friend, their homes had a pungent odor, its from the fried fish dishes they would make, they also had a funk from fermented fish dishes they ate. Tumeric is quite pungent, as many other Indian spices. While the number of Japanese that dont soak at all is less than 5%. Zombie Survivalist. There are 6 of them who come over at any given time Theyre too young for body odor. Two swipes of two pits will save you a lifetime of despair. When SCA compared the results across cultures, they found that "Russian women have to contend with the biggest demands for the attributes of beautyjewelry, makeup and shaved legsfrom those closest to them. Each dataset provided population totals for a different set of ancestries. You can learn about Sanjay here or check out his YouTube channel here. EAST Asians have a gene called the ABCC11 gene. Its standard practice in the Muslim world to wash yourself with water after having gone to the toilet, rather than using paper, which is why in the Middle East youll find TP a rarity. Thanks for the great article. Hey, thank for such a nice comment and sharing your story. But again, unscented deodorant is available..so you dont smell like a pretty flower, saying HEY BOYS, IM PRETTY. So my other best friend and I did what good friends do. Women's bathing rituals were more diffuse, but about 60 percent preferred to shower three, four, or five times weekly. If someone wears enough scented stuff so that being 50 feet downwind makes me feel ill, chances are its too much. When theyre saying, Go home, terrorist, or those types of slurs, its quite obvious Im othered, Damavandi, 25, said. Most EAST Asians and 99% of Koreans, yet, only 2% of Europeans have this! You should be proud of where you come from, said Shabbar, now a graduate student at Cal State Northridge. These Western toilets were used as squatters by people not accustom to sitting while . It smells sour. The smell has now set and it will be hell to get it out. What habits and ways of thinking are common in Weird societies thatpeople living elsewhere inthe world might find, well, weird? Water is preferred, for example, in a number of majority-Muslim countries, as Islamic teachings include the use of water for cleaning. Cookie Notice Beydoun, who is Egyptian and Lebanese, served on a committee of field experts that provided the Census Bureau with feedback on the idea of a MENA box on the 2020 census. And when i would walk from one side of the club to other, It was like almost guaranteed I would smell multiple people stinking of BO. Body Odor has a bacterial component. The average American showers nearly every day, which is, according to a Euromonitor poll, the global average as well. In Italy we wipe, then we use a thing called bidet to wash our intimate parts, ofc only when were home, otherwise we just wipe and wash ourselves once we get back. - Quora. NO, NOT the Indian one, the one who didnt apply deodorant, duh! Americans spend 9.9 minutes under the water, us Brits 9.6 minutes, and the Germans half a minute less. And then those same guys start trolling people online because they have a frustrated sex life or who knows what. Sitting as the no. Also meaning, it is NORMAL to sweat and smell bad (without perfumes or/and chemicals to mask or/and block the smell or/and sweat). There is a tendency to expect early showering in Western societies, or getting wet every day, and thats weird, reflects Elizabeth Shove, a sociologist at the University of Lancaster who researches water and energy consumption practices. Its really an issue for me since Im sensitive to horrible smells. In addition to those resources, advocates argue, the white label could hurt universities and companies that use the information to promote diversity and could result in the gathering of little or no statistical data on important issues, such as health trends in the community. Over the last decade, it seemed the tide would turn the Obama administration was considering proposals to ask questions about race and ethnicity in a different way, shifting not only how the government would count the Middle Eastern community, but the Latino population as well. If you find a nice or anonymous way to tell them they smell, guess what? Its just that the Indian one may be the one who didnt! We wash on 30 to 40 degrees nowadays, temperatures at which bacteria will not die easily. I add this, because the curry smell ISNT body odor. For sure body odor it caused about sweat + bacteria. There wasnt a discussion about identity, or what it would mean to properly classify the community. ditto on the stink and natural remedies though! Either way lets hope people start discussing it more openly and find ways to share with random people a nice way of saying hey put some deo.. I felt this was insanely well written I dated an indian man he didnt smell, but today my god did I experience this. Also Pakistanis dont put really strong spices in their food like Indians either. The tongue-in-cheek campaign encouraged people to choose some other race and sought to combat the notion that Arabs and Iranians are white an idea that experts say has roots in a legal battle from the early 1900s. The squat toilet neatly avoids excessive bum-to-seat intimacy. BUTwhy SHOULD they? Southern California, New York and Detroit have the largest groups of people from Southwest Asia, North Africa and the Middle East. The results of this research indicate that it is optimal to use a dedicated Middle Eastern or North African response category, a 2017 census report said. It cant get clean enough for bacteria to go away. One dab in the morning will keep you going until 10 PM, even in that crazy Chennai or Mumbai summers. Many are attached to mosques. Also, quit being a bastard. Not to mention that you can find dog poop on any sidewalk, this increases the bad smell of the city. My classmate told me being an Indian Muslim girl meant they couldnt wear deodorant. For instance, Brits were still mostly using hard toilet paper in the 1970s, as they distrusted the soft paper being purveyed by Americans. All of the families look out for each other, and they trust us with their kids, just as we trust them with ours. The overall population of roughly 3 million was drawn from the American Community Survey's ancestry question and a 2015 study by the census. Mexicans and Japanese people come closest to fully sanitizing their hair each time. Find the cure, not just resort to deodorant. Rep Power: 471. No this sounds different then what I know. NextShark met with Marie Kondo, author of the best-selling book The Life-Changing Magic of Tidying Up: The Japanese Art of Decluttering and Organizing. (Turkeys Directorate of Religious Affairs did however issue a fatwa in 2015 specifying that Muslims can use toilet paper if water isnt available.) That will increase your money, career, dating, love life and probably personal happiness. So, if you see an Indian approaching you, the best you can do is practice meditation and stop your brain from creating false signals of stink. He uses anti-perspirant just for sports. Still, much of the West relies on toilet tissue including the UK and US. The definition on hygiene isnt the practice the habit of smelling good and appealing to others. Im weak. BOTH. I couldnt help but wonder if my scent lingers in the house like theirs did. It was awful. My 7 year old has only Indian friends at home, she has grown up with them, and we live like a village, where all of the kids are in and out if each others homes all day every day. Many South Indian (Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad) also put oil in their hair in the morning (coconut usually) which also has a unique smell. Many Ghanaians, Filipinos, Colombians and Australians, among others, also bathe multiple times a day. Home Travel Why Do Middle Easterners Not Shower. For many, a write-in doesnt go far enough because they identify as people of color. Even so, those trends didnt penetrate everywhere. I dont know in particular, but if I had to guess its possible in the Indian house there is a strong smell of either incense, or the spices from the cooking in the kitchen. What all Chinese parents will tell you is: dont read on the toilet. While Arab countries might widely vary in many traditions and aspects, most of them agree to the great good: cleanliness. The Muslims also popularized dental hygiene. This article is part of our Weird West series. If you smell curry, it isnt from the sweat seeping from their pores. Shes sitting opposite of my desk, so very close to me for several hours every day. You want to spend an hour with coconut oil and lotions every evening, be my guest. Back in 2010, a team at the University of British Columbia pointed out thatpsychology research contains a major flaw: much of it is based on samples entirely from Western, Educated, Industrialised, Rich and Democratic or Weird societies. I had a friend who had all the money in the world, worked at McKinsey, went to Harvard, yet couldnt land a date if his life depended on it. But heres the thing, I think even the Indians or south Asians who shower everyday, SOME of them will naturally start smelling quickly. In the UK, Pakistanis are involved in MMA and sports all the time in the northern towns. Dr. Sanjay Jain recently told Jezebel that "showers don't need to be too hot, or too long, and you should always pat dry, rather than rub, to avoid irritating your skin." my wife is from Hong Kong too though so Ill ask her about this . open with a compliment), but maybe nobody has told you but you smell. But if you eat cumin, garlic, fenugreek and hing in sufficient quantities, your skin will smell like them even if you don't use deodorant. I picked a window seat and was enjoying my podcasts when an Indian gentleman entered the bus and sat beside me. Although they did not invent the toothbrush or toothpaste, Muslim doctors helped advance knowledge of the mouth and teeth, and the need to keep them clean. Most Indian houses have strong smells linger throughout the day, which can be alarming to some. Meanwhile, Youssefs beloved bum gun is commonly found in Finland. The researchers often assumed that their findings would be applicable to people anywhere. Game over for that shirt. thanks for sharing! We chickened out and wrote an anonymous email because we didnt want to hurt his feelings (more so for our own selfish reasons but we wanted to help. Just sharing my thoughts here upon reading this article. Answers is the place to go to get the answers you need and to ask the questions you want To himself, he was confused beyond belief. Anyway, I think it comes only out if you dont have a correct hygiene, or if you maybe sweat due to physical effort or heat. The U.S. Census Bureau offers a narrow definition, known as MENA, which includes all people, regardless of race, who claim ancestry from a limited set of countries in the Middle East and North Africa. Well, in India, I have seen many people saying that white tourists smell horrible if they dont put some deo or fragrance. But the availability of water isnt the only factor affecting this. I dont have his email or any friend I can perform the fake deodorant dialogue with. Although no guarantees on the last one. Maya Berry, executive director of the Arab American Institute, said this lack of proper representation has deprived our community of access to basic services and rights, such as language assistance at polling places and educational grants. Eventually she had to go to an Indian-owned store. Toilets in Japan That is the bathroom. Finland 78.9. Yet the impure soap cannot purify the rest of the body that needs something purer. Im curious, why you say toilet paper is disgusting? Some swear by the alertness brought about by a morning jolt of water, but an evening bath, as is common in Japan, can help with relaxation of muscles before bed. the Korean man! India is about 5-10 years behind on the BO elimination wave, and the more we help our friends and family realize theyre adding some stank into the mix, the more we all benefit. Alters the composition of sweat. Some of these bacteria come directly from the mother at birth. We are talking about body odour and youre bringing up deodorant.