Asking whether an exact duplicate of a soul is any different from the original is a question for the Philosophy Stackexchange site. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. I even held one in my hand. Why cant the soul stone bring back the dead? The soul stone has effectively chosen him because of the sacrifice of Black Widow. Just speaking in the perspective of feats, which I thought if there's a price to pay for it, this kind of weakens the Infinity Gauntlet's power because there's something it cannot do. Vanessa Kirby Fantastic Four Casting Comments. Did Roger Zelazny ever read The Lord of the Rings? The Earth has now become a warzone with several alien invasions . Returning the stone simply wouldn't bring the dead one back. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. It would also showcase Adam Warlocks powerful abilities while also setting up his connection to the Soul Stone and the world inside, something which was barely touched upon in Infinity War. Are there causes of action for which an award can be made without proof of damage? We repeat: MAJOR spoilers for the movie lie below. How did Red Skull get cursed? deal, rather than a how. As a movie only fan, I know very little else of the comic universe, but I have seen a handful of videos. Reels. As fans learned back in Ant-Man, the Quantum Realm (or Microverse in the comics) is an alternate dimensions you can enter by magical means or through Pym Particles. I'm going to quote the DMG, p. 24, under "Bringing Back the Dead", but the section before that quoted in Goopbgone's answer:. Could it have been used in conjunction with the Time Stone to restore him? The character is expected to play a pivotal role in the future of the MCU and his first order of business could be in bringing back Vision. Natasha Romanoff was just getting to become the Avengers makeshift leader while Captain America was off attending a veterans support group. There was no Avengers 5 on the list. In the Secret Empire series, she dies but it turns out a secret program has repeatedly cloned her, and one of the clones ends up with her memories, effectively rebooting her character. Will they just simply die in double suicide or will the stone reveal a hidden nature and resurrect them both along with itself? Is there a lack of precision in the general form of writing an ellipse? And what does the soul stone even do on its own ? Are there any other agreed-upon definitions of "free will" within mainstream Christianity? You have to give up something to get the stone, not "lend something and be given it back once you're done.". The time stone can partially rewind time, or loop time, or.. something else? and our And theres a long history of stories where heroes who nobly give up their lives for the greater good are brought back by a higher power. Or, perhaps more easily, the stone on its return simply doesn't release the Red Skull because it knows his purpose has not truly been fulfilled. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. WebCan the soul stone bring people back from the dead? It took years before someone told me this but Warlocks, you can Soulstone dead party members during combat. Why cant the soul stone bring back the dead? Does the Soul Stone always need a sacrifice? In the comics, Adam came to possess the stones after defeating Thanos and subsequently attempted to bring balance to the universe by splitting his own soul. fullmetal alchemist series - Anime & Manga Stack Exchange LATE ENGR. RAYMOND ANTHONY ALEOGHO DOKPESI - Facebook Even Loki, a villain turned semi-hero, seemingly died in Thor: The Dark World, came back for Thor: Ragnarok, died again in Avengers: Infinity War, and is back in play due to time-travel shenanigans as of Avengers: Endgame. @MikeScott We don't even know if they're exact. Would it really be that bad if the Soul Stone was not The process for earning the Soul Stone is irreversible. Even if you have returned it to its original location, you wouldnt be able to get the person back. Hes back in WandaVision, though he is still presumed dead. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray Yet she was sad and cold, separated from him as by a veil. Can Soul Stone Bring Back Life? - Caniry Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. And then shed apparently be missing from her original timeline, though Endgame notably glosses over any effects that would have on anything other than an Infinity Stone. 2 could appear and bring back Vision from the dead for real. It would be as simple as a good guy getting the gauntlet and freeing them from the stone. This is important because of your question. The movies never even explained it . Its already been established that the movie will feature time travel, right? After sparking up a dying star and reactivating the forge to channel its raw energy, the foursome craft Thors killer new weapon: the hammer-meets-battle-ax known as Stormbreaker. Statement from SO: June 5, 2023 Moderator Action, Starting the Prompt Design Site: A New Home in our Stack Exchange Neighborhood, Latest Blog Post: The First Officer: Alpha Protocol Book 2, Favorite Question and Answers from Second Quarter 2023. But itd still give the other Avengers a goal to rally behind in the next sequel. And if he managed to return the Soul stone anyway, then he can also bring back Scan this QR code to download the app now. Combining every 3 lines together starting on the second line, and removing first column from second and third line being combined. A soulFor a soul. Except for the simple action of reviving a very specific person! But the film itself contains a clue: Thanos killed his daughter Gamora in Infinity War to obtain the stone, and shes alive and well by the end of Endgame. Related:Thor 4 Should Introduce Adam Warlock, NOT Guardians of the Galaxy 3. How could they return the Infinity Stones in their "raw" form? How can I know if a seat reservation on ICE would be useful? There's no indication in Infinity War that the Red Skull is freed once the stone is taken. Back in chapter 6, God said He was bringing a sword upon Israel and would scatter their bones (6:3-5). WebSoulstone the dead, Warlocks. rev2023.6.27.43513. and 538 B.C.). So the condition for Red Skull's release may have never actually been achieved: the stone just moved around a bit, nothing more. This is why I hate to think in depth about time travel and cosmic-level stories, the logic proposed by writers often made no sense. Avengers: Infinity War held a lot of heroes, but there was one important one missing. You can't pick and choose. Bringing back dead characters is an overdone comic book trope, but it makes more sense if Adam were the one to do it considering that the Soul Stone is a big part of his story arc and one of his primary domains. Strange then attempted to use the Stone against Maw only to be overpowered and brought aboard Maw's Q-Ship.Mid-flight, the torturer attempted to force Strange into surrendering the Stone only for him to be slain by Stark and Peter Parker.Though Strange wanted to head back to Earth, Stark convinced him Thanos [Spoilers] A few quick questions regarding Infinity War Returning the stone simply wouldn't bring the dead one back. Episode 4: Eyes of Science. Where did Gamora find the Map to the Soul Stone? Privacy Policy. See the interviews above that clearly and definitely state it doesn't work like that - Nat's dead, period. Unless we actually see this event portrayed in a future movie, or the directors decide to offer an official explanation, we can't know for sure. A trope of sacrifice/self-sacrifice. WebAmen. Since holding the Tesseract in his hand at the end of Captain America: The First Avenger, Red Skull had been cursed to serve as the keeper of the Soul Stone on Vormir. Why else would he not speak about his new found life to his friends. Cut the head now the head now, cut the head now, cut the head, Cut the head, there is a sword in your hand, child of God. But is it possible to create a completely new copy using the deathold and mindstone like wandavision and AOS? The comics have the stones wanting to be together but the comics also have a price - corruption. But that would be a frustrating echo of what happened with Gamora, just as Natashas death was a frustrating echo of Gamoras more emotionally resonant murder. Thanos did kill her to trade her soul for the Soul Stone in Infinity War, but with all the time travel The two had a short conversation, but fans of the comics were interested in dissecting the setting. I think the words used by Red Skull are that the Soul Stone requires an "everlasting sacrifice", Could they not have grabbed a copy from earlier that day? How common are historical instances of mercenary armies reversing and attacking their employing country? She names this perfect being Adam, though the mysterious figure never actually appears in the film and only his birth pod (reminiscent of the comics) shows up to tease his eventual arrival. You could use the Reality Stone to No, that's not the way it works.there's no indication that returning the stone would bring Nat back to lifein fact loss of life isn't technically required, only that you lose what you love. Granted the nature of the Hallows -- being either unique artifacts of unique power, or merely super well enchanted items with standard powers, it would be fitting for the "spirits" to merely be duplicates, as in the case of paintings and ghosts. Thatd be a cheap solution, but given how unclear the mechanics of the Soul Stone are (who exactly is keeping it hidden and demanding these deaths?) [EDIT: u/aar7745 has clarified that even in the comics, where a Soul World does exist, the snapped people do not go there, they die. We dont actually see this part of the film play out, but Im sure it mustve been a hell of an adventure for Cap! Why didn't the resurrection stone 'work'? All rights reserved. Romanoff tells Banner the procedure is carried out because its one less thing to worry about while on a mission. You could use the Time Stone to reverse their death if it was recent enough. As for the logical argument, it can actually be argued the other way too. Red Skull says claimants for the Soul Stone have to give up something they love, but Hawkeye doesnt sacrifice Black Widow the way Thanos sacrificed Gamora Black Widow jumps willingly, and Hawkeye fights her all the way. The Red Skull survives the exposure due to the effects of the Super-Soldier Formula. Im not sure if thats what happened in the comics (the Wikipedia description mentions some individual people being trapped in the soul stone, but does use the word killed when referring to the people who were snapped, so idk) but we have no reason to believe that the MCU will be faithful to the comic storyline, especially since its been so drastically different in pretty much every other plot point. Also, the once-dead person will want to return to the afterlife because that is where they belong and are happiest. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. Can't someone like Thor just use the gauntlet to bring him back ? Reddit, Inc. 2023. plot explanation - How can the Soul stone be returned?
How To Not Get Choked Up When Speaking, Articles C